De. Rothstein et Dr. Zak, Relationships between plant nitrogen economy and life history in three deciduous-forest herbs, J ECOLOGY, 89(3), 2001, pp. 385-394
1 We compared nitrogen (N) uptake and whole-plant N dynamics in three decid
uous-forest herbs of contrasting life histories: the spring ephemeral Alliu
m tricoccum, the summergreen Viola pubescens and the semievergreen Tiarella
cordifolia. We predicted that differences in above-ground physiology would
translate into differences in N acquisition and partitioning, such that ni
trogen-use efficiency (NUE) would increase from Allium to Viola to Tiarella
.
2 Patterns of N uptake were generally the opposite of our predictions. Alli
um had the lowest N uptake capacity in both laboratory and field experiment
s whereas roots of Tiarella had the highest specific N uptake capacity.
3 Viola was the only species in which the specific uptake capacity of roots
was related to photosynthetic activity of leaves, both decreasing by a fac
tor of two from spring to summer. In contrast, Tiarella consistently had th
e lowest photosynthetic capacity and the highest specific uptake capacity w
hereas Allium maintained substantial root uptake capacity throughout the su
mmer when it had no photosynthetic activity.
4 There were no significant differences between species in overall NUE. How
ever, there were differences in the components of NUE: nitrogen productivit
y (A) and mean residence time of N in the plant (MRT). Nitrogen productivit
y increased, and MRT decreased, from Allium to Viola to Tiarella.
5 In all three species, there was a balance between acquisition of N and bu
ilding of biomass over the annual growth cycle, despite dramatic disjunctio
ns between the tissue-specific rates of carbon and N acquisition in Allium
and Tiarella. The variation in A and MRT we observed among co-occurring spe
cies of a single N-rich habitat was comparable with that observed by other
researchers studying plants adapted to habitats of widely varying N availab
ility.