Purpose: The European Collaborative MMT4-91 trial was conducted as a prospe
ctive nonrandomized study ta evaluate the potential benefit of high-dose me
lphalan as consolidation of first complete remission in children with stage
IV rhabdomyosarcoma,
Patients and Methods: Fifty-two patients in complete remission after six co
urses of chemotherapy received "megatherapy": 42 received melphalan alone,
whereas 10 received melphalan in combination with etoposide, carboplatin/et
oposide, or thiotepa/busuifan and etoposide, The outcome of this group of p
atients was compared with that observed in 44 patients who were also in com
plete remission after six courses of identical chemotherapy (plus surgery o
r radiotherapy) but went on to receive a total of up to 12 courses of conve
ntional chemotherapy (four cycles). No differences were found between the t
wo groups regarding clinical characteristics, chemotherapy received before
complete remission, or response to chemotherapy, In particular, there war n
o significant difference between the groups for site of primary tumor, hist
ologic subtype, age at presentation, presence of bone or bone marrow metast
ases, or number of metastases.
Results: The 3-year event-free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) Kit
es were 29.7% and 40%, respectively, far those receiving high-dose melphala
n or other multiagent high-dose regimens and 19.2% and 27.7%, respectively
for those receiving standard chemotherapy. The difference was not statistic
ally significant (P = .3 and P = .2 for EFS and OS, respectively), There wa
s a significant prolongation in the time from the last day of high-dose che
motherapy or the end of chemotherapy cycle 4 to the time of relapse in thos
e receiving megatherapy (168 days far patients receiving megatherapy v 104
days far those receiving standard therapy; P =,05),
Conclusion: The addition of a high-dose alkylating agent to consolidation t
herapy may have prolonged progression-free survival in this poor-risk patie
nt group, but it did not significantly improve the ultimate outcome.